Makerdao

Makerdao continues as Sky with Dai, USDS and token-holder governance

Updated

Makerdao is the decentralized governance project behind Dai, whose stablecoin system now operates as Sky Protocol. Its collateral-backed lending, savings and governance functions use different tokens and contracts. Borrowing creates debt with liquidation risk, while the governance transition means legacy MKR voting instructions no longer describe the active system.

Dai, Vaults and governance tokens perform different jobs

Dai is the stablecoin that the Multi-Collateral Dai system issues against approved collateral, with a soft target of one US dollar. Vaults record the collateral and debt that support issuance, while governance determines eligible assets and the risk settings that constrain borrowing. A Dai balance, a collateral position and voting power therefore represent different relationships with the same protocol. Buying or receiving Dai gives its holder a transferable token without assigning that holder the original borrower’s Vault debt.

USDS extends the stablecoin side of the Sky ecosystem, while SKY now carries governance voting power. MKR is the legacy governance token and remains relevant to conversion and withdrawal from older voting contracts.

Collateral turns Dai issuance into a debt position

Generating Dai against collateral increases a Vault’s debt, and the collateral must satisfy the risk rules for its particular type. The Vat, the core accounting contract, records these balances, and collateral adapters connect external tokens to that accounting system. The CDP Manager adds identifiable Vault positions and ownership management, using the older term collateralized debt position that predates the Vault name.

A Stability Fee accrues on outstanding debt. The Jug contract updates the accumulated fee for a collateral type, which changes the debt recorded through the Vat. Borrowing capacity also depends on collateral valuation and the relevant debt ceiling. Extra collateral doesn’t create additional borrowing capacity when that ceiling already prevents new debt. Paying down debt reduces the obligation; withdrawing collateral requires the remaining position to satisfy its safety rules. Full withdrawal from a crypto-collateral Vault before liquidation requires settlement of its debt and accrued fees.

Ethereum transaction costs remain separate from the Stability Fee. The liquidation penalty applies when liquidation occurs, so it represents a different charge from ordinary debt accrual.

Oracle prices and auctions govern collateral liquidation

An insufficiently collateralized crypto Vault can enter liquidation, which transfers collateral and debt into the protocol’s liquidation machinery. Keepers submit transactions that trigger eligible liquidations and participate in collateral purchases. Liquidation 2.0 uses Dutch auctions that settle purchases immediately. Its Dog contract initiates the process, and the Clipper contract handles the collateral sale through configurable time-dependent price curves. A reset or governance change can increase an active auction’s price, so a falling-price design doesn’t make every later purchase cheaper.

Oracle prices

The Oracle Security Module delays collateral price updates on a configured schedule so authorized actors can respond to suspect prices. Late updates can shorten that response window. It also means a current exchange quote and the price driving protocol calculations can differ. Network congestion or missed updates can further affect when the system receives usable price information.

Auction settlement

Debt recovery

The auction collects Dai toward the liquidated debt, accrued Stability Fees and liquidation penalty. Purchases can take part of the available collateral, while global and collateral-specific auction limits can constrain how much debt enters liquidation at once.

Unsold collateral

The sale stops once it meets its collection target or exhausts the collateral. Any unsold collateral can return to the designated owner; liquidation doesn’t promise recovery of the original deposit.

The Sky transition changed governance and token conversion

The 2024 rebrand introduced Sky, USDS and SKY into the project’s existing stablecoin ecosystem. That change followed an earlier expansion: Multi-Collateral Dai arrived in November 2019 after the original single-collateral system, whose token became known as Sai. The later governance cutover moved active voting from MKR and Chief V2 to SKY and Chief V3. The legacy voting portal now only supports withdrawing MKR from delegate contracts and Chief V2.

The MKR-to-SKY converter’s base ratio is 1 MKR to 24 000 SKY before the delayed-upgrade penalty. Converter V2 supports one-way conversion within the protocol, and its governance-configured fee reduces the SKY output. The base ratio therefore doesn’t establish the net amount received. The converter’s current fee setting determines that reduction. Earlier descriptions of reversible conversion belong to the previous arrangement.

Dai savings and sUSDS accrue through different contracts

The Dai Savings Rate and Sky Savings Rate attach accrual to deposited stablecoins through separate contracts. The Ethereum converter exchanges Dai and USDS at a 1:1 token ratio in either direction. This conversion changes the stablecoin held; access to savings involves a separate contract relationship.

Dai Savings Rate

The Pot contract implements the Dai Savings Rate, or DSR, and uses an accumulator to track deposited savings over time at the governance-set rate. Holding Dai in an ordinary wallet doesn’t activate this contract’s accrual. Supplying existing Dai to savings doesn’t create a collateral-backed debt for the depositor, and the applicable rate can change through governance.

Sky Savings Rate

Depositing USDS into the savings Vault gives the holder sUSDS shares through an ERC-4626 contract, following the tokenized vault standard. The contract calculates conversions between shares and underlying USDS, so a share balance and its redeemable asset amount describe different quantities. The Sky Savings Rate governs accrual, so treating each sUSDS unit as permanently equal to one USDS would misread the position. USDS withdrawals use the applicable share-to-asset relationship. USDS also supplies the separate Sky Ecosystem Rewards module, which can distribute participating ecosystem tokens and points.

Stablecoin liquidity and real-world assets shape the backing

Collateral backing and trading liquidity contribute differently to a stablecoin’s dollar target. The LitePSM supplies a conversion route involving Dai and USDC, while its USDS wrapper shares the underlying liquidity. Available balances constrain swaps, and governance controls route fees and halt settings. These mechanisms support exchange around the target without ensuring that every market trade matches it. A token conversion ratio also doesn’t establish an unconditional claim to dollars in a bank account.

Real-world assets, or RWAs, add off-chain financial claims to the backing arrangements. The established RWA Vault design relies on governance-approved operators and legal agreements. Its collateral recovery can require enforcement and settlement outside Ethereum. Those dependencies differ from selling crypto collateral through a Clipper auction. An on-chain accounting balance alone doesn’t complete recovery of an off-chain asset. Governance, counterparties and the relevant legal arrangement determine how that claim works in practice.

Makerdao - Stablecoin liquidity and real-world assets shape the backing - diagram

View full-size image

Votes authorize changes through governance contracts

SKY voting can change protocol settings, but proposal support and executed changes represent different states. Governance Polls gather preferences, while Executive Votes support code that changes the system. Chief handles proposal selection, Pause enforces a configured execution delay and a Spell carries the approved actions. A successful vote doesn’t establish that execution has already occurred. The resulting contract settings determine the rates and limits that affect stablecoin users, even when those users don’t participate in voting. Authorized modules and collateral adapters hold powerful permissions within the accounting system, so faulty code or harmful governance changes can affect collateral and balances.

Participation routes require different starting assets

Existing Dai supports transfers or savings deposits, while additional issuance requires a collateral position with borrowing capacity. SKY voting and USDS savings use other assets and contracts.

Participation routes require different starting assets
Activity Asset or position required
Transfer Dai Dai in a wallet on the transfer network
Generate Dai Accepted collateral in a Vault that permits additional debt
Use the Dai Savings Rate Dai to deposit into the savings contract
Convert Dai and USDS Dai or USDS for the Ethereum converter
Deposit into sUSDS USDS for the savings Vault
Vote or delegate in Sky governance SKY for a compatible voting or delegation contract
Use the Staking Engine SKY to deposit; sufficient collateralization for optional USDS borrowing

USDS savings and SKY staking create different exposures

The Staking Engine connects a SKY deposit to staking rewards, voting delegation and optional USDS borrowing, while the deposited asset remains a governance token with a market price. The Smart Burn Engine directs protocol surplus into open-market SKY buybacks, with governance settings determining whether the protocol burns those tokens or distributes them as staking rewards. Borrowing adds a debt obligation and liquidation exposure to that position. Rewards and borrowing terms follow their own settings, so a staking reward estimate doesn’t describe the cost of a loan. The Sky portal’s available functions can also vary by jurisdiction.

Depositing USDS into the stUSDS module funds SKY-backed borrowing and gives the depositor stUSDS tokens. Its risk-capital design absorbs a greater share of system risk in exchange for potential rewards, with its own rate. sUSDS instead represents shares in the Sky Savings Rate mechanism. Choosing USDS savings, stUSDS lending or SKY staking therefore changes both the underlying asset exposure and the contract that governs accrual.

Questions people ask about Makerdao

Does the Dai-to-USDS converter charge a protocol fee?

The Ethereum Dai-to-USDS converter charges no protocol fee in either direction. Ethereum transaction costs remain separate. An exchange or aggregator can use a different route, so the converter’s fee rules don’t establish the costs of every Dai or USDS trade.

Can a Dai permit signature authorize spending without moving tokens immediately?

A Dai permit signature authorizes a spender without itself transferring Dai. The signed permission can update the token allowance when someone submits it to the contract. Once the token contract accepts a permit authorizing spending, the spender has unlimited allowance, so an approval signature can have consequences even without an immediate payment.

What sets the minimum debt for a collateral Vault?

The collateral type’s debt-floor parameter, called dust, determines its minimum nonzero debt. This floor differs from the debt ceiling, which limits total issuance for that collateral type. Both depend on the applicable configuration, so a minimum quoted for one Vault type doesn’t establish the requirement for every other type.

When can governance pause liquidation auctions?

Governance can restrict liquidation activity through the Clipper circuit breaker, using ClipperMom to bypass the usual governance delay. Its levels distinguish new auctions, auction resets and purchases from existing auctions. Disabling new liquidations doesn’t necessarily stop existing collateral sales; the selected level determines which operations remain available.

Are Staking Engine positions transferable between wallets?

A Staking Engine SKY Vault can’t transfer to another address. This differs from collateral Vault ownership management through the CDP Manager. The Staking Engine also keeps its internal staked balance within the position, so that balance isn’t a freely transferable wallet token.

Is USDS functionality fixed permanently?

USDS uses an upgradeable token contract that permits governance-approved implementation changes. The Dai-to-USDS conversion ratio describes the exchange relationship between tokens. It doesn’t promise that the USDS token’s implementation will remain unchanged.

Will a direct DSR withdrawal include all accrued savings?

When savings have accrued, a direct DSR withdrawal needs an updated accumulator to include the full amount. The Pot contract’s drip function refreshes that accounting. Exiting without an update can omit savings accrued since the previous update. This concerns DSR contract integration, not the share-conversion design of sUSDS.

How private are Dai payments on Ethereum?

Dai transfers on Ethereum are publicly visible. Wallet balances and transaction histories reveal asset movements, so using a crypto wallet doesn’t make a stablecoin payment confidential. The token’s stable-price target describes its intended value, not transaction privacy.